A few months ago, we heard this from Plato. It was his way of determining who loved truth and who didn’t.
What I proposed was having our children be told glorious tales to stir their imaginations, very much stressing all the time that these tales were true, and then seeing which among the children can resist them, can see the logical inconsistencies within these tales, and see all their inconsistencies with other truths that they have been told.
Here’s another truth-loving test, from C.S. Lewis’s book, Mere Christianity. (In the book, he did not propose this as a truth-loving test, but I think it makes an excellent one.)
The real test is this. Suppose one reads a story of filthy atrocities in the paper. Then suppose that something turns up suggesting that the story might not be quite true, or not quite so bad as it was made out. Is one’s first feeling, “Thank God, even they aren’t quite so bad as that,” or is it a feeling of disappointment, and even a determination to cling to the first story for the sheer pleasure of thinking your enemies are as bad as possible?
I read the quote over at Slacktivist’s blog. He had earlier treated the theme in a wonderful post called Jackie at the crossroads. In that story, a young woman named Jackie has claimed there are poisonous spiders in airport restrooms, former stow-aways on international flights. When she is shown that this is just an urban legend, she has a choice: she can double-down or laughingly admit her gullibility. Her choice is a very clear window on her character.
How about us? When we learn that the rumor we have spread about our political or religious adversaries is unfounded, is our first reaction to be relieved that they are not so bad after all? Or do we double down by finding another way they are so bad, or by calling the refutation “biased” even though it is our own bias that has just been exposed?
Pingback: Voltaire’s Truth-Loving Test in Candide | Path of the Beagle
Pingback: A Chess Player’s Truth-Loving Test | Path of the Beagle
Pingback: A UFO Nut’s Truth-Loving Tests | Path of the Beagle
Pingback: The Fearless Person’s Truth-Loving Test | Path of the Beagle
Pingback: Nietzche’s Truth-Loving Test | Path of the Beagle
Pingback: A Fact-Checker’s Truth-Loving Test | Path of the Beagle